Optimizing Phone Screen Interview: Tips and Tricks

While technology advances rapidly, the phone screen interview remains a crucial component of the hiring process, particularly in light of the increasing prevalence of remote and virtual work settings. To help you refine your phone interview skills and achieve optimal outcomes, we will explore the best practices for conducting phone screen interviews, reliable strategies, and a helpful tool for maximizing the interview experience, along with common pitfalls to steer clear of. Let's begin!

How to Conduct a Phone Screen Interview?

Hiring through phone screen interview questions is a key step in the recruitment pipeline. This initial screening helps you determine if a candidate meets the basic requirements for the job before moving on to more extensive interviews. Here are some tips and strategies to effectively prepare for a phone screen interview:

• Review candidates' resumes: Before the phone screen interview, carefully examine the candidate's resume to identify their relevant work experience, skills, and qualifications that match the job requirements. This will enable you to customize your interview questions accordingly.
• Prepare a list of questions: Compile a set of pertinent questions to pose to the candidate during the phone screen interview. These questions should center around the candidate's background, skills, and reasons for applying to the position. Consider incorporating behavioral and situational inquiries to evaluate how the candidate handles specific scenarios.
• Maintain a professional demeanor: When conducting the phone screen interview, uphold a professional atmosphere throughout the discussion. Ensure you are in a quiet, unobtrusive environment and communicate clearly and professionally to convey a sense of professionalism to the candidate.
• Practice active listening: Active listening plays a crucial role in a phone screen interview. Give full attention to the candidate's responses, and ask follow-up questions to clarify any points or delve deeper into their answers. This will help you obtain more insights into the candidate's qualifications and suitability for the role.
• Take detailed notes: Make it a point to jot down notes during the phone screen interview for future reference. Record any key highlights, strengths, or areas of concern that could impact your decision on advancing the candidate in the recruitment process.
• Offer informative guidance: As a recruiter, it is important to provide candidates with comprehensive details about the company, the job position, and the subsequent steps in the hiring process. This will assist candidates in gaining a clearer perspective of the opportunity and determining if it aligns with their career objectives.
• Evaluate cultural fit: Utilize the phone screen interview as an avenue to assess candidates' cultural compatibility with the organization. Pose questions about their work approach, communication style, and teamwork tactics to gauge their suitability for the company culture.
• Follow-up: Following the phone screen interview, ensure to reach out to candidates to offer feedback and outline the next stages. Maintain professional and courteous communication, even if candidates are not chosen to progress further in the recruitment process.

While interviewing, you can leverage a recruitment tool like Manatal’s Applicant Tracking System (ATS) to ensure a smooth process and make the most of the information you get from the candidates. During the interview, you can write down candidates’ qualities, skills, experience, etc., and put it into Manatal’s database. You can also create notes on certain candidates, allowing hiring managers to view and reply to notes, in case they are interested in moving on with the candidates or dropping them. Plus, Manatal helps you make a seamless collaboration through its notes system where you can keep all stakeholders on the same page.

{{cta}}

How to Collect and Record Feedback During Phone Interviews

Take Detailed Notes

During the phone interview, make sure to take detailed notes on everything the candidate says. Note down their responses to each question, any key points they make, and any interesting insights they provide. This will help you remember important details later on when discussing the candidate with other team members.

Use a Rating Scale

Create a rating scale that allows you to quickly evaluate the candidate’s responses to each question. This can be a simple scale from 1 to 5, with 1 being poor and 5 being excellent. This will help you objectively assess each candidate and compare them to others.

Record the Interview

With the candidates’ permission, record the phone interview so that you can refer back to it later when making your decision. Recording also allows you to share the interview with team members who were not present during the call, ensuring that everyone has the same information when evaluating the candidate.

Ask for Feedback from Others

After the phone interview, reach out to other team members who were involved in the hiring process and ask for their feedback on the candidate. Have them share their thoughts on the candidate’s qualifications, experience, and overall fit for the role. This way, you’ll have a diverse range of opinions to consider.

Use a Feedback Form

Create a feedback form that team members can fill out after the phone interview. Include questions that prompt them to evaluate the candidate’s communication skills, technical abilities, and cultural fit. This is how you can gather consistent feedback from all team members involved in the hiring process.

Schedule a Debrief Meeting

Schedule a debrief meeting with all team members involved in the phone screen interview to discuss their feedback and impressions of the candidate. Allow everyone to share their thoughts and insights, and work together to come to a consensus on whether or not to move forward with the candidate.

Mistakes to Avoid During a Phone Screen Interview

• Lack of preparation: One common mistake recruiters make during phone screen interviews is not adequately preparing for the conversation. This can lead to a disorganized and unproductive interview, potentially causing the candidate to lose interest in the role. So, it’s a good idea to review the candidate's resume, prepare relevant questions, and familiarize yourself with the job description before the call.
• Not setting clear expectations: Another mistake is failing to clearly communicate the purpose and expectations of the phone screen interview to the candidate. It is important to explain the interview process, timeline, and next steps to ensure that candidates know what to expect and can adequately prepare for the discussion.
• Poor communication skills: You should be mindful of your communication skills during a phone screen interview. Talking too fast, using jargon, or interrupting candidates can lead to misunderstandings and a negative candidate experience. Instead, speak clearly, listen actively, and maintain a professional demeanor throughout the conversation.
• Asking inappropriate questions: Questions related to race, religion, marital status, age, or disability are off-limits and can potentially lead to discrimination claims. Stick to job-related questions that assess candidates' qualifications and fit for the role.
• Lack of engagement: Remember, a phone screen interview is your opportunity to engage with candidates and assess their interest in the position. Failing to show enthusiasm, ask follow-up questions, or actively listen to the candidate's responses can give the impression that you’re not interested in engaging in a conversation with candidates. So, go out there and demonstrate genuine interest and engagement throughout the conversation.
• Rushing through the interview: Rushing through the phone screen interview to save time is not the right way to wrap up your task. It’s a must to take your time to assess candidates' qualifications, experience, and fit for the role. All of these aspects will help you make informed decisions.

Conclusion

As mentioned earlier, phone screen interview plays a big role in the hiring process, helping you identify the qualified candidates before proceeding to face-to-face interviews. To ensure a successful phone screen interview, it is a must to be well-prepared before picking up the phone. By going through these tips and tricks, there are high chances that you can streamline your recruitment process and better identify top talent. Before we go, remember that a well-conducted phone screen interview is the first step in finding the perfect candidate for the job.