Choosing the Right Personality Test for Jobs in Your Hiring Process

A company's culture affects how employees feel and work. When employees' personalities match the company's culture, they are usually happier and work better. For example, outgoing people may thrive in a team-focused company, while those who prefer working alone may do better in a more independent environment. Using a personality test for jobs can help find candidates who fit well with the company's culture. Consider using a personality test in your hiring process to build a stronger and more united team!

When Do Recruiters Need Personality Tests?

When using a personality test for jobs in your hiring process, it’s important to have a clear plan. A checklist or questionnaire can help you pick the right test, match it to your company’s goals, and use the results properly. Without proper planning, personality tests could lead to bad hiring choices or legal problems.

Now, ask yourself these questions before you decide if you should use a personality test for jobs:

1. What is your primary objective for using personality tests?
2. What traits are most important for success in the roles you’re hiring for?
3. How will the test results influence your decision-making process?
4. Are your hiring managers trained to interpret personality test results?

Implementing Personality Tests for Recruitment

Pre-Implementation

1. Define the Purpose
   • What is the primary goal of the personality test? (e.g., cultural fit, leadership potential, team dynamics)
   • How will the results be used in the hiring or development process?
2. Understand the Role
   • What specific personality traits or characteristics are important for the role?
   • Are there existing benchmarks for success in this role?
3. Select the Test
   • Is the test scientifically validated and reliable?
   • Does it measure traits relevant to your objectives (e.g., Big Five, DISC, MBTI)?
   • Is the test culturally appropriate for your candidates?

Implementation

1. Communicate with Candidates
   • How will you explain the purpose of the test to candidates?
   • Will you offer candidates access to their results?
2. Ensure Fairness
   • Are all candidates being given the same test under similar conditions?
   • Is there a strategy to prevent bias in the interpretation of results?
3. Train Stakeholders
   • Are hiring managers trained to understand the test results?
   • Is there a plan to combine test results with other evaluation tools?

Post-Implementation

1. Evaluate Effectiveness
   • Have personality tests improved hiring outcomes?
   • Are there any noticeable trends or feedback from candidates or hiring managers?

Deploying the Test

Once you’ve selected the right personality test for your hiring goals and job requirements, the next step is implementing it effectively in your recruitment process.

1. Integrate the Test into Your Hiring Workflow
   • Begin by informing candidates about the test. Clearly explain why you’re using it and how the results will contribute to the hiring decision. Transparency fosters trust and encourages participation.
   • Ensure a consistent approach by administering the test uniformly to all candidates at the same stage. This keeps the process fair and unbiased.
2. Deploy the Test with Manatal’s ATS
   Manatal’s applicant tracking software (ATS) makes integrating personality tests seamless. You can easily set up the process using:
   - Workflow Automation: With Workflow Automation, you can automate the sending of tests when candidates reach a specific stage in your pipeline.
   - Built-in Integrations: Leverage tools like TestTrick to send personality assessments directly from the platform.‍
3. Analyze and Act on Results
   ‍Once the tests are completed, ensure the results are reviewed by a trained professional who can match insights to the job's requirements. This ensures your decisions are data-driven and aligned with the role’s needs.

Sourcing candidates shouldn't be hard

Source & hire candidates faster with Manatal's ATS.

Sign up for Free

Types of Hiring Personality Tests You Should Know

Personality tests are a valuable tool in the hiring process, helping employers understand candidates' traits and how they might fit into a team or role. While there are many options available, some tests are more widely used and proven effective. Here are four key personality tests you should be familiar with:

1. The Big Five Personality Test

Renowned for its scientific basis, the Big Five Personality Test evaluates five major dimensions of personality:

• Openness to Experience: Reflects curiosity, creativity, and willingness to embrace new ideas. Facets include imagination, intellect, and adventurousness.
• Conscientiousness: Measures reliability and organization. Facets include self-discipline, responsibility, and attention to detail.
• Extraversion: Gauges sociability and energy levels. Facets include assertiveness, enthusiasm, and activity.
• Agreeableness: Assesses friendliness and cooperation. Facets include trust, empathy, and altruism.
• Neuroticism: Examines emotional stability and resilience. Facets include anxiety, vulnerability, and moodiness.

This test provides a nuanced understanding of a candidate's personality, offering insights into their workplace behavior and interpersonal dynamics.

2. The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)

The MBTI is one of the most popular personality assessments worldwide. Based on Carl Jung's theory of psychological types, it categorizes individuals into 16 personality types using four dichotomies:

• Extraversion (E) vs. Introversion (I): How individuals draw energy—externally or internally.
• Sensing (S) vs. Intuition (N): How they perceive information—through tangible facts or abstract ideas.
• Thinking (T) vs. Feeling (F): How they make decisions—logically or emotionally.
• Judging (J) vs. Perceiving (P): How they approach structure—planned or flexible.

For example, a candidate might be an ENFP (Extraverted, Intuitive, Feeling, Perceiving) or an ISTJ (Introverted, Sensing, Thinking, Judging), offering valuable insights into their preferences and work style.

3. The DISC Personality Test

The DISC test focuses on four behavioral styles, making it a practical choice for hiring:

• Dominance (D): How individuals address problems and challenges.
• Influence (I): How they interact with and persuade others.
• Steadiness (S): How they handle pace and change.
• Compliance (C): How they approach rules and procedures.

Each style reveals strengths, weaknesses, and preferred work environments. For instance, a "D" personality may be decisive and assertive, while an "S" personality may excel in supportive and stable roles.

4. The Enneagram Personality Test

The Enneagram test offers a dynamic framework, categorizing individuals into nine personality types based on their core motivations, fears, and desires. Each type is interconnected through:

• Wings: Adjacent types that add nuance to the core personality.
• Arrows: Directions indicating growth or stress responses.

Some examples of Enneagram types include:

• Type 1 (The Reformer): Motivated by a desire for integrity and excellence.
• Type 4 (The Individualist): Driven by a need to express uniqueness and authenticity.
• Type 7 (The Enthusiast): Inspired by a pursuit of happiness and freedom.

This test is particularly useful for understanding how candidates handle challenges, adapt to stress, and thrive in teams.

Personality Tests That Are Suitable for Recruitment

Not all personality tests are designed for recruitment, so it’s important to choose carefully. Using a test that isn’t reliable or validated for hiring decisions can lead to poor outcomes. A good test should provide consistent results when taken under similar conditions and have certification for its reliability and validity. Many tests on the market don’t meet these standards and should be avoided. To help you make the right choice, here’s a list of recommended personality tests for recruitment, known for their accuracy and effectiveness.

1. The Caliper Profile

The Caliper Profile evaluates candidates' traits and motivations to predict their job performance and potential for success. Backed by over 60 years of research, it measures 22 key personality traits and identifies motivations relevant to specific roles. Its results are versatile, supporting various stages of the employee lifecycle, including hiring, development, promotion, team building, and succession planning.

2. Hogan Personality Inventory

The Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI) assesses an individual's positive or "best self" personality traits, offering insights into how they interact with others at their best. It helps employers understand how candidates manage tasks, lead teams, and their potential for success.

3. HEXACO Personality Inventory

The HEXACO Personality Inventory measures six key dimensions of personality: Honesty-Humility, Emotionality, Extraversion, Agreeableness (versus Anger), Conscientiousness, and Openness to Experience. This tool helps recruiters identify candidates who are well-suited to their organization's culture and roles.

4. Berke Assessment

The Berke Assessment is a simple questionnaire that estimates an individual's traits and abilities in problem-solving. This personality test is quite a hit amongst recruiters as it helps over 700 organizations accomplish their hires.

5. SHL Occupational Personality Questionnaire (OPQ)

The SHL Occupational Personality Questionnaire (OPQ), established over 30 years ago, is used worldwide for hiring. It assesses job performance and suitability by evaluating an individual's routine behavior and can be applied to candidates at all levels, from entry-level to executives.

6. The Predictive Index

The Predictive Index is a widely used personality test trusted by companies like Subway and AutoNation for recruitment, powered by behavioral science. In just 10 minutes, candidates select words that describe how others expect them to act and how they see themselves. This test quickly reveals candidates' thinking styles and work behaviors, making it an excellent choice for understanding their motivations.

Why Employers Are Using Personality Tests

Personality tests provide valuable insights into how well candidates will fit within your organization, increasing the chances of long-term retention and reducing the effort needed to fill the role. While a 40-minute interview can highlight a candidate’s skills and experience, it doesn’t assess their cultural fit. Here’s how personality tests help:

Cultural Fit: Assessing cultural fit helps determine if a candidate will thrive in your company’s environment, promoting better teamwork and productivity. Personality tests offer insights into whether a candidate aligns with your company culture.

Role & Team Fit: Personality tests reveal how well candidates collaborate with teams, handle challenges, and demonstrate leadership when necessary, providing early insights into their potential.

Communication Style & Preference: Understanding a candidate’s communication style helps ensure they absorb and share information effectively, fostering a productive and efficient work environment.

What Personality Tests Tell Us

Generally, personality tests reveal candidates' traits, such as adaptability, communication preferences, leadership potential, and cultural fit. This, in turn, helps you understand how they will perform in specific roles and integrate into a team. Here’s how this type of assessment can help you make better hiring decisions.

Information Acquisition (How the Candidate Absorbs Information)

In simple terms, this refers to how candidates learn. Understanding how candidates acquire new knowledge, skills, and attitudes helps employers make better hiring decisions. Employees who are eager to learn and develop are essential to any business. If someone lacks the willingness to learn, they may struggle to grow, affecting the company’s productivity.

Decision-Making Skills (Leadership Under Pressure)

Decision-making is a crucial skill for all employees. In business, employees will eventually face challenges that require quick decisions, often under pressure. Those who can stay calm, assess the situation, and make thoughtful decisions will help drive the company toward its goals. Personality tests help employers identify candidates with strong decision-making abilities under stress.

Process & Rational Thought (Problem-Solving Skills)

Problem-solving is another key skill for employees. When problems arise, employees need to find solutions quickly and efficiently. Personality tests can identify candidates who are skilled at using both standard and creative approaches to resolve issues.

Organizational Skills & Time Management (Productivity)

Employees who can organize tasks and manage time effectively contribute to better performance and increased productivity. Personality tests reveal which candidates can set clear goals, stay focused, and manage their time efficiently. Employers can use this insight to select candidates who will help boost the company’s productivity.

Conclusion

In conclusion, personality tests provide valuable insights that help employers make more informed hiring decisions. By assessing key traits like learning ability, decision-making, problem-solving, and organizational skills, these tests reveal how candidates are likely to perform in specific roles and contribute to team dynamics. Understanding these aspects early in the hiring process enables employers to select candidates who are not only qualified but also a good fit for the company's culture and goals, ultimately leading to better productivity and long-term success.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the role of personality tests in filtering job candidates?

A: Personality tests play a key role in filtering job candidates by providing insights into an applicant's behavioral traits, work style, and cultural fit:

• Identify Key Traits: Help employers identify candidates with attributes like teamwork, leadership, and adaptability that are essential for success in specific roles.
• Informed Hiring Decisions: Evaluate personality traits alongside resumes and interviews to reduce turnover and improve team dynamics.
• Bias Reduction: Expose potential biases in the hiring process, ensuring a more equitable and objective candidate evaluation.
• Align with Company Values: Contribute to building a workforce that aligns with the company’s values, improving productivity and job satisfaction.

Q: How are personality tests used in the job hiring process?

A: Personality tests are increasingly used by employers to evaluate candidates beyond just their skills and experience. These assessments help employers gain insights into important traits that contribute to workplace success. Key traits assessed often include:

• Teamwork: Ability to collaborate effectively with others.
• Leadership: Capacity to motivate, guide, and manage teams.
• Adaptability: Willingness and ability to adjust to changing circumstances.
• Interpersonal Skills: Ability to communicate and build relationships with colleagues.

Q: How accurate are job personality tests?

A: Job personality tests can be accurate in predicting how someone might fit into a job role, especially when they are based on reliable models like the Big Five personality traits. However, their accuracy depends on the test's design, the context, and whether the person answers truthfully. While helpful, they should be used alongside other factors like skills and experience, not as the only measure for hiring decisions.

Q: Are there any drawbacks to using job personality tests?

A: While job personality tests offer insights, they also have several drawbacks. Here are some of the concerns:

• Bias: Job personality tests can introduce bias, potentially favoring certain demographics over others, leading to unfair hiring practices.
• Oversimplification: These tests may reduce complex human behaviors and personalities into simple categories, overlooking the uniqueness of individuals.
• Test Preparation: Candidates might prepare for personality tests, resulting in answers that don’t truly reflect their authentic selves.
• Overreliance: Relying too heavily on personality tests can cause employers to overlook important factors like skills, experience, and cultural fit, possibly missing out on qualified candidates.

Q: How can recruiters determine which personality test is best suited for their organization?

A: Recruiters can choose the best personality test for their organization by considering a few key factors:

• Assess Needs and Goals: Identify the key traits that align with company culture and job requirements.
• Evaluate Reliability and Validity: Ensure the test is scientifically backed and has a proven history of success.
• Pilot Testing: Test the assessments with current employees to see how they align with company values and performance outcomes.
• Stakeholder Input: Involve stakeholders to ensure the test enhances recruitment and onboarding processes.

Q: How can I measure the impact of personality tests on employee performance?

A: Measuring the impact of personality tests on employee performance can be approached through several methods:

• Performance Metrics Analysis: Track key performance indicators (KPIs) before and after implementing personality assessments to see if there is a change in productivity or team cohesion.
• Employee Feedback: Conduct regular surveys to gather qualitative data on employee satisfaction and team dynamics, providing insight into the influence of personality tests on workplace behavior.
• Correlation Studies: Correlate personality traits identified by tests with actual performance outcomes, such as sales figures, project completion rates, and retention rates, to assess their effectiveness.

By using both quantitative and qualitative approaches, you can gain a comprehensive understanding of the relationship between personality tests and employee performance.